Strangeness and Beauty: Unanswered Questions in Cosmology and Space-Time
Wisdom may begin in wonder, but there's always more mystery to uncover
Within the vast expanse of the cosmos, mysteries abound, challenging our understanding of the universe's origin, evolution, and fundamental nature. In this essay, we embark on a journey to explore some of the most challenging problems confronting current cosmological models, as well as questions of why we are even here at all — what is matter, really? — along with the confounding nature of time itself.
It’s Awfully Quiet for a Big Bang
The Inflationary Model of Big Bang Cosmology has been a cornerstone in our understanding of the universe's early moments. However, it faces significant challenges that prompt a rigorous evaluation of prevailing cosmological paradigms. The initial density perturbation, flatness problem, horizon problem, and monopole problem are among the persistent challenges encountered by the Inflationary Model [1]. These issues cast doubt on its explanatory power and necessitate alternative frameworks for understanding cosmic evolution.
Time, in particular, presents a perceptual puzzle that eludes comprehension, definition, and precise measurement — it could be that even Planck time itself is malleable, for instance, due to as-of-yet unknown phenomena that remains to be identified and explored.
Dark Matter, Dark Energy, Black Holes, and the Multiverse Hypothesis
The majority of the universe is, theoretically, composed of dark matter and dark energy — and yet, true to their namesake, their compositions remain elusive. Understanding the properties and interactions of these components is crucial for comprehending the large-scale structure and evolution of the cosmos. Black holes, regions of spacetime where gravitational forces are so intense that nothing, not even light, can escape, pose many unanswered questions about their formation, behavior, and the ultimate fate of objects that fall into them. Some theories suggest that our universe is just one of many in a vast "multiverse," each with its own physical laws and properties, raising profound questions about the nature of reality and the potential for other forms of existence beyond our own reality.
Moreover, certain exotic phenomena predicted by the Inflationary Model have not been observed, raising valid concerns about its completeness and accuracy [1]. These discrepancies highlight the need for a more comprehensive cosmological theory that can account for observed phenomena while addressing theoretical inconsistencies. In contrast to the abrupt beginning proposed by the Big Bang theory, Cyclic Cosmology posits a continuous cycle of expansion and contraction, incorporating principles from string theory and quantum fluctuations [2]. By addressing the singularity problem and providing a framework for understanding cosmic evolution without the need for an initial singularity, Cyclic Cosmology offers a promising avenue for further exploration. Additionally, it provides potential solutions to some of the deficiencies observed in the Inflationary Model, and could help to explain other enduring mysteries of physics, such as the mechanisms of the strong force that binds matter together as quarks, which make up protons and neutrons in atomic nuclei. However, Cyclic Cosmology is not without its own challenges and unanswered questions. Further research and observational evidence are needed to fully assess its validity and explanatory power.
We must embrace cross-disciplinary exploration, drawing upon insights from beyond philosophy and physics.
Quantum Mechanics, Consciousness, and Space-Time
The interplay between quantum mechanics and space-time presents further challenges to our understanding of fundamental physics. Bohmian mechanics, for instance, offers a deterministic interpretation of quantum phenomena, challenging conventional interpretations based on probabilistic outcomes [5]. Emerging theories suggest that space-time itself may emerge from quantum correlations, highlighting the intricate relationship between quantum entanglement and temporal dynamics [6]. This suggests a profound interconnectedness between quantum phenomena and the fabric of space-time, challenging traditional notions of causality and determinism.
In the realm of quantum mechanics, concepts like superdeterminism and retrocausality challenge conventional notions of causality and temporal order [3][4]. Superdeterminism suggests that all events are predetermined by a hidden set of variables, undermining the concept of free will and challenging our understanding of causality, i.e. “time’s arrow”, as flowing only forwards through time. Retrocausality, however, proposes that future events can influence past events, leading to nonlocal and nonsequential causal relationships — in this case, Time’s Arrow flows backward, and the future determines the past. While these concepts may seem counterintuitive, as thought experiments, they offer new perspectives on the nature of time and causation in the quantum realm. Some versions of the Standard Model suggest that there are subatomic particles, such as tachyons, that may indeed travel backwards in relation to our inertial frame of reference, causing for us to experience time as moving forward.
As we grapple with the complexities of cosmology and quantum mechanics, the nature of time remains a profound enigma. From philosophical ponderings to mathematical formulations, the perception of time eludes precise definition [7]. For example, Rashevsky's work in the field of Mathematical Biophysics raised fundamental questions about the physicochemical interpretation of spatial perception and the nature of consciousness [8]. By exploring the biophysical aspects of space and time, researchers seek to uncover the underlying mechanisms that give rise to our perception of reality. Scholars and modern physicists confront the challenge of reconciling subjective experience with objective reality, shedding light on the intricate tapestry of consciousness and temporal perception.
Alternative interpretations of quantum mechanics raise philosophical questions about the nature of reality and the role of consciousness in shaping our perception of the universe. In the pursuit of understanding, we must also acknowledge the limitations of human perception and cognition. Time, in particular, presents a perceptual puzzle that eludes comprehension, definition, and precise measurement — it could be that even Planck time itself is malleable, for instance, due to as-of-yet unknown phenomena that remains to be identified and explored. From the deliberate philosophical musings of ancient thinkers to the oftentimes surprise discoveries of modern physicists, the nature of time remains a subject of fascination and debate.
There’s Still “Plenty of Room at the Bottom”
While many people will say there are no new physics, unanswered questions abound, inviting exploration and contemplation. The mysteries of cosmology and time continue to inspire curiosity and drive technological innovation. We must embrace cross-disciplinary exploration, drawing upon insights from beyond philosophy and physics. Through radical collaboration and restless inquiry, we continue to push the boundaries of human knowledge, our successes marked by a willingness to challenge entrenched beliefs. As we attempt to map the bounds of the universe and the labyrinths of temporal perception, we are not merely observers but active participants in the unfolding drama of creation and discovery. In our quest for understanding, we find not only answers, but also new questions, beckoning us ever onward into the realms of the unknown. By unwavering dedication to rigor, we embark on a journey of exploration and discovery, propelled by the boundless curiosity that has driven humanity since the dawn of our species. Wherever we go, we carry with us the knowledge that the universe is unknowably vast, yet waiting to be explored - as we hope to grasp some of its ultimate mysteries.
References
[1] Siegel, Ethan. "The Big Bang Wasn't the Beginning, After All." Forbes. [Link](https://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2017/09/21/the-big-bang-wasnt-the-beginning-after-all/?sh=66ca444255df)
[2] Discover Magazine. "This Cyclic Model of the Universe Has Cosmologists Rethinking the Big Bang." [Link](https://www.discovermagazine.com/the-sciences/this-cyclic-model-of-the-universe-has-cosmologists-rethinking-the-big-bang)
[3] Backreaction. "The Forgotten Solution: Superdeterminism." [Link](http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2019/07/the-forgotten-solution-superdeterminism.html?m=1)
[4] Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. "Retrocausality." [Link](https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qm-retrocausality/)
[5] Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. "Bohmian Mechanics." [Link](https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qm-bohm/)
[6] Quanta Magazine. "Time Entanglement Raises Quantum Mysteries." [Link](https://www.quantamagazine.org/time-entanglement-raises-quantum-mysteries-20160119/)
[7] Cambridge Core. "The Biophysics of Space and Time." [Link](https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/philosophy-of-science/article/abs/biophysics-of-space-and-time/8615DD41CCFB9331722A8256112AFAF9#)
[8] Springer Link. "Biophysical Aspects of Time and Motion." [Link](https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-540-70626-7_221)
[9] Quanta Magazine. "Physicists Rewrite a Quantum Rule That Clashes with Our Universe." [Link](https://www.quantamagazine.org/physicists-rewrite-a-quantum-rule-that-clashes-with-our-universe-20220926/?mc_cid=fa30821f35&mc_eid=8e33d3edf2)
[10] The Marginalian. "Time Travel." [Link](https://www.themarginalian.org/2016/09/27/james-gleick-time-travel/)
[11] Figmentfly. "Institute for Figuring - The Hyperbolic Crochet Coral Reef." [Link](https://www.figmentfly.com/bb/institute6.html)
[12] Levin, Michael. "Morphological Computation." [Link](https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF02478216)
Help us make Hyperdrive Anthropology a more enriching experience by telling us what you think! Readers who complete the survey and share their favorite article to social media get one month free, on us. Just give your opinion here and then ReStack or share the blog:
Subscriber Referrals Program
Invite your friends and colleagues to read our blog and earn rewards!
Affiliations
I use Notion to organize my ideas. Free to use for single users on a basic plan, with an intuitive interface, highly customizable workspaces, dozens of integrations, AI assistance, and more. When you sign up for paid plan using my affiliate link, I get commissions, which are tremendously helpful.
Google Workspace is the engine that runs most of this operation, from the domain hosting and site building, to email and machine learning tools and free learning programs and credits towards building a startup. When you sign up using my referral code, you’re also giving us a boost. Thanks!